English
Cost Approach Fundamentals
Chapter 27: Cost Approach Fundamentals
Introduction
The cost approach is a valuation method where the value of a property is estimated by summing the land value and the depreciated cost of the improvements. This chapter delves into the fundamental principles, scientific theories, and practical applications of the cost approach in real estate valuation.
- Core Principles
1.1 Principle of Substitution
The cost approach is firmly rooted in the principle of substitution. This principle posits that a rational buyer will not pay more for a property than the cost of acquiring an equivalent substitute. In the context of the cost approach, the substitute is the option of purchasing vacant land and constructing a new building.
Mathematical Representation:
Value (Property) ≤ Cost (Land) + Cost (New Building) - Depreciation
1.2 Principle of Contribution
The principle of contribution asserts that the value of any component of a property is determined by its contribution to the overall value. In the cost approach, improvements contribute to the property’s value, but this contribution is reduced by depreciation.
1.3 Principle of Balance
This principle states that the cost of the improvements should be proportional to the value of the site.
Mathematical Representation:
Optimization = f(Land Value, Improvement Cost)
If the ratio between the land and improvement costs deviates significantly from the market norm, over- or under-improvement scenarios can occur, leading to potential value losses.
- Components of the Cost Approach
2.1 Land Value
Land valuation is a critical first step in the cost approach. Land value must represent its highest and best use as though vacant. Several methods are used to determine land value, including: - Sales Comparison Approach: Comparing the subject land to similar parcels that have recently sold. Adjustments are made for differences in size, location, zoning, and other relevant factors.
- Extraction Method: Estimating land value by subtracting the depreciated cost of the improvements from the overall property value.
Land Value = Property Value – Depreciated Cost (Improvements) - Allocation Method: Allocating a percentage of the total property value to the land, based on market-derived ratios.
2.2 Cost Estimation
Accurately estimating the cost of constructing a new building or improvements is fundamental. Two primary cost concepts are:
1. Reproduction Cost: The cost of creating an exact replica of the existing structure, using the same materials, design, and construction❓ methods. This method is often impractical due to changes in building codes, technology, and materials.
2. Replacement Cost: The cost of constructing a building with equivalent utility, using current materials, design, and construction standards. Replacement cost is the more commonly used and practical approach.
Methods for Cost Estimation:
1. Quantity Survey Method: A detailed breakdown of all labor, materials, equipment, overhead, and profit required to construct the building. This is the most comprehensive and accurate method but also the most time-consuming.
2. Unit-in-Place Method: Estimating cost by calculating the cost of individual building components (e.g., walls, roofs, floors) installed in place.
Total Cost = Σ (Quantity × Unit Cost)
3. Comparative-Unit Method (or Square-Foot Method): Applying a cost per square foot or cubic foot derived from similar recently constructed buildings.
Total Cost = Area × Cost per Unit Area
Example: A 2,000 sq ft building with an estimated cost of $150 per sq ft would have a total cost of $300,000.
4. Index Method: Using cost indexes to adjust historical costs for changes in price levels over time.
Current Cost = Original Cost × (Current Index / Original Index)
2.3 Depreciation
Depreciation is the loss in value of a property due to physical deterioration, functional obsolescence, and external obsolescence. Accurately estimating depreciation is crucial in the cost approach.
1. Physical Deterioration: The wear and tear on a building due to age, use, and exposure to the elements.
Types:
Curable: Cost-effective to repair (e.g., painting, minor roof repairs).
Incurable: Not cost-effective to repair (e.g., structural issues, extensive foundation problems).
2. Functional Obsolescence: A loss in value due to inadequacies in the building’s design or utility, making it less desirable compared to modern standards.
Types:
Curable: Cost-effective to remedy (e.g., adding an extra bathroom).
Incurable: Not cost-effective to remedy (e.g., poor layout, low ceiling height).
3. External Obsolescence: A loss in value due to factors external to the property itself, such as changes in the surrounding neighborhood or economic conditions. This is generally incurable from the perspective of the property owner.
Methods for Estimating Depreciation:
1. Age-Life Method: Based on the ratio of the building’s effective age to its total economic life.
Depreciation = (Effective Age / Economic Life) × Total Cost
Example: A building with an effective age of 20 years and an economic life of 50 years has a depreciation rate of 40%.
-
Market Extraction Method: Estimating depreciation by comparing the cost of new buildings to the selling prices of comparable older buildings.
Depreciation = Cost (New) – Market Value (Old) -
Breakdown Method: Identifying and quantifying each type of depreciation (physical, functional, and external) separately. This is the most detailed and accurate method.
-
Capitalized Income Method:
Calculate income that is lost due to item and capitalize.
Lost income / capitalization rate = Depreciation due to item. -
Mathematical Formulation of the Cost Approach
The cost approach can be summarized by the following equation:
Property Value = Land Value + (Reproduction or Replacement Cost – Total Depreciation)
Value = L + (C – D)
Where:
L = Land Value
C = Cost (Reproduction or Replacement)
D = Total Depreciation -
Practical Applications and Related Experiments
4.1 Example Application
Consider a commercial building:
Land Value (L): $200,000
Replacement Cost (C): $800,000
Physical Deterioration: $50,000
Functional Obsolescence: $30,000
External Obsolescence: $20,000
Total Depreciation (D) = $50,000 + $30,000 + $20,000 = $100,000
Property Value = $200,000 + ($800,000 - $100,000) = $900,000
4.2 Related Experiments (Comparative Studies)
1. Depreciation Sensitivity Analysis: Varying depreciation rates to understand their impact on overall value.
2. Cost Estimation Comparison: Comparing the results of different cost estimation methods (Quantity Survey, Unit-in-Place, Comparative-Unit) to identify discrepancies and refine accuracy.
3. Economic Life Determination: Researching and comparing economic lives of similar buildings in the market to validate the chosen economic life for the subject property.
- Challenges and Limitations
- Subjectivity in Depreciation Estimates: Depreciation estimation often relies on judgment and can be subjective.
- Accurately Estimating Costs: Obtaining accurate cost data can be difficult, especially for specialized or unique properties.
- Applicability: The cost approach is most reliable for new or relatively new properties and less reliable for older properties with significant depreciation.
- Entrepreneurial Profit: Estimating the correct entrepreneurial profit can be difficult, which affects costs.
- Market conditions: The cost approach does not incorporate market conditions such as supply and demand.
- External obsolescence: Difficult to estimate.
-
Assumes highest and best use: The cost approach assumes that the current improvements are the best use for the land.
-
Conclusion
The cost approach is a valuable tool in real estate valuation, grounded in scientific principles and practical methodologies. By understanding the core concepts of substitution, contribution, and balance, and by employing accurate cost estimation and depreciation techniques, appraisers can derive reliable value estimates, particularly for properties where the sales comparison and income capitalization approaches may be less applicable or reliable.
Chapter Summary
The “Cost Approach Fundamentals” chapter of the “Real Estate Valuation: The Cost Approach Masterclass” training course covers the theoretical underpinnings and practical application of the cost approach to real estate valuation.
Key scientific points and conclusions:
- Definition and Applicability: The cost approach estimates value❓ by summing the land value and the depreciated cost of improvements. It is most applicable to newer properties representing the highest and best use as though vacant, where it is based on the idea a buyer would consider building new instead of buying existing.
- Principle of Substitution: The approach relies on the principle of substitution, stating that a buyer will pay no more for a property than the cost of acquiring a similar site and constructing a new improvement. This simulates a buyer’s thought process when considering new construction versus existing buildings.
- Balance Principle: The cost of the improvement must be proportional to the site value. Overimprovements exist when the investment in the building is disproportionately high relative to the land value.
- Supply and Demand: Short-term changes in real estate demand may lead to price changes, but supply will increase in the long run as new units are built.
- Common Errors: Common mistakes include inaccurate depreciation estimates, land value miscalculations, overstating construction quality, and ignoring reconfiguration costs (functional obsolescence).
- Cost Estimation and Depreciation: Application of the cost approach requires current knowledge of construction techniques and costs to properly estimate replacement or reproduction costs, and depreciation.
Implications:
- The cost approach offers an independent valuation method, particularly useful for unique or specialized properties where market data is scarce.
- Understanding construction costs, depreciation, and land economics is crucial for accurate application.
- The cost approach is most reliable when the improvements are new or relatively new and represent the optimal use of the land. Its accuracy diminishes with older, obsolete, or substandard properties.
- The chapter emphasizes the importance of considering the relationship between the land value and the improvement costs in determining the overall property value, as dictated by the balance principle. A disproportionate investment can lead to overimprovement and reduced marketability.
- Proper application requires avoiding subjective data and manipulating costs to align to a predetermined value.
- The cost approach provides insight to developers considering the balance between land acquisition costs and construction costs.
