English
Cooperative & Timeshare Interests: Structures & Valuation Overview
Cooperative & Timeshare Interests: Structures & Valuation Overview
Introduction
This chapter provides a comprehensive overview of cooperative and timeshare interests, focusing on their unique structures and the methodologies employed in their valuation. Understanding these intricacies is crucial for accurate appraisal and informed decision-making in real estate.
- Cooperative Interests
1.1 Structure of Cooperatives
A cooperative (co-op) is a type of real estate ownership where residents own shares in a corporation that owns the building. Unlike condominiums, where residents directly own their units, co-op residents hold a Proprietary lease❓❓ granting them the right to occupy a specific unit.
1.1.1 Share Allocation
The number of shares allocated to a unit is typically determined by factors such as size, location, and amenities. The price per share dictates the total purchase price for an occupant.
1.1.2 Proprietary Lease
This lease outlines the rights and responsibilities of the shareholder, including the monthly maintenance fee.
1.1.3 Monthly Maintenance Fee
This fee covers the co-op’s operating expenses, debt service on the underlying mortgage, and maintenance of common areas. The board of directors, elected by the shareholders, can adjust this fee.
1.1.4 Financing Structures
Historically, co-ops relied on blanket mortgages for the entire building. Shareholders either paid 100% equity or secured personal notes for their share purchases. Now, individual shareholders can mortgage their shares.
1.2 Advantages and Disadvantages of Cooperative Ownership
1.2.1 Disadvantages
- Complex financing structure: Owners pay for their unit loan and a share of the blanket mortgage.
- Co-op restrictions: Subletting may be prohibited.
- Social exclusivity: The board of directors has significant influence over sales.
1.2.2 Advantages
- Shareholder control: Shareholders elect directors, influencing property conditions.
- Potential for social exclusivity: Stricter rules and vetting can enhance community.
1.3 Valuation Considerations for Cooperatives
1.3.1 Factors Influencing Value
- Location
- Unit size and layout
- Building amenities
- Financial health of the cooperative
- Market conditions
- Restrictions on subletting and resale
- Underlying mortgage and associated risks
1.3.2 Valuation Methods
The valuation of cooperative interests typically involves adapting standard real estate appraisal methods, considering the specific characteristics of co-ops.
Sales Comparison Approach: Analyzing recent sales of comparable co-op units, adjusting for differences in features, location, and financial aspects.
Income Capitalization Approach: Estimating the potential rental income if subletting were allowed (considering restrictions) and capitalizing this income stream. This approach is limited by subletting restrictions.
Cost Approach: Estimating the replacement cost of the building, deducting depreciation, and adding land value. This is less common due to the challenges in accurately estimating depreciation and land value in urban areas.
- Formula for Market Value (MV):
MV = Sales Price + (Comparable Advantages - Comparable Disadvantages)
- Timeshare Interests
2.1 Types of Timeshare Interests
Timesharing involves the sale of limited ownership or usage rights to residential units. There are two main categories: deeded and non-deeded interests.
2.1.1 Deeded Interests
Fee Timesharing: Purchaser receives a deed conveying title to a unit for a specific period each year. The interest can be sold, leased, mortgaged, or bequeathed.
Floating Time: Purchaser has the right to use a unit during a specified portion of the year at a resort or group of resorts.
Timeshare Ownership: Purchaser receives a deed to a particular unit as a tenant in common, agreeing to use it only during the stipulated time.
Interval Ownership: Ownership lasts for the project’s duration, reverting to interval owners as tenants in common, who can then sell, divide proceeds, or renew.
2.1.2 Non-Deeded Interests
Right-to-Use: Purchaser obtains the right to use a unit and related premises for a specific period.
Points-Only: Purchaser acquires points that can be used at various resorts within a network or vacation club.
Leasehold Interest: A prepaid lease arrangement.
Vacation License: Developer transfers a license to the purchaser, granting the right to use a unit for specified periods.
Club Membership: Purchaser buys membership in a club that owns, leases, or operates timeshare properties.
2.2 Timeshare Market Structure
The timeshare industry operates on a two-tiered market:
- Primary Marketplace: Sales by resort developers to individual buyers.
- Secondary (Resale) Marketplace: Resales by individuals who purchased from developers or in the secondary market.
Market participants and sales processes differ significantly between these markets. Appraisers must use sale prices from the relevant market.
2.3 Valuation Considerations for Timeshares
2.3.1 Factors Influencing Value
- Resort location and amenities
- Time of year (seasonality)
- Unit size and quality
- Type of timeshare interest (deeded vs. non-deeded)
- Resale restrictions
- Demand and supply in the timeshare market
- Maintenance fees and assessments
- Exchange program affiliations
2.3.2 Valuation Methods
Valuing timeshares requires considering the unique characteristics of these interests.
Sales Comparison Approach: Analyzing recent sales of comparable timeshare interests in the same or similar resorts. Adjustments must account for differences in seasonality, unit size, and amenities.
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Analysis: Estimating the future rental income potential of the timeshare interest and discounting it back to present value.
Formula for Present Value (PV) of Cash Flows:
PV = CF1/(1+r) + CF2/(1+r)^2 + … + CFn/(1+r)^n
Where:
CF = cash flow
r = Discount rate❓❓
n = number of periods
Cost Approach: Less applicable due to the difficulty in allocating costs and accounting for depreciation.
2.4 Ethical Considerations
Appraisers must be aware of potential biases and misrepresentations in the timeshare market. Accurate and unbiased valuations are essential.
2.5 Practical Applications and Related Experiments
2.5.1 Case Study: Cooperative Apartment Valuation
A cooperative apartment in Manhattan is being appraised. Comparable sales data indicates a price range of $800 to $1200 per share. The subject apartment has 1,000 shares. A detailed analysis of the building’s financial statements and market conditions reveals that a price of $1100 per share is reasonable.
2.5.2 Experiment: Sales Comparison for Timeshares
Collect sales data for timeshares at a specific resort. Analyze the data to determine the impact of seasonality, unit size, and view on sale prices. Create a regression model to predict timeshare values based on these factors.
Conclusion
Cooperative and timeshare interests present unique challenges in valuation due to their complex structures and market dynamics. A thorough understanding of these structures, combined with appropriate valuation methods, is crucial for accurate and reliable appraisals. By considering the factors outlined in this chapter, appraisers can provide informed opinions that support sound decision-making in the real estate market.
Chapter Summary
This chapter provides an overview of cooperative and timeshare interests, focusing on their structures and valuation considerations. Cooperatives involve ownership of shares in a corporation that owns the property, granting shareholders a proprietary lease❓ for a specific unit. Shareholders collectively cover operating expenses❓ and debt service through monthly maintenance fees, and shareholder voting influences property conditions. Financing options include blanket mortgages on the entire property and individual shareholder mortgages. Disadvantages of cooperative ownership can include complex financing structures, restrictions on subletting, and potential social exclusivity, whereas advantages can be more control over property conditions.
Timesharing involves the sale of limited ownership interests or rights to use residential units. There are deeded interests, which convey title for a specific period, and non-deeded interests, which grant right-to-use privileges. Deeded interests include specific recurring periods and floating periods, while non-deeded interests encompass right-to-use arrangements and points-based systems. Deeded timeshares can be classified as timeshare ownership (tenant in common) or interval ownership (ownership for the project’s duration). Non-deeded timeshares include leasehold interests, vacation licenses, and club memberships.
The timeshare market operates on two tiers: the primary market (developer sales) and the secondary market❓ (resales by individuals). Appraisers must use comparable sales from the relevant market, as primary market transactions often include incentives not transferable to the secondary market.
The valuation process requires a clearly defined scope of work, tailored to the specific assignment. This involves identifying the appraisal problem, determining the appropriate solution, and applying that solution. Key elements of the assignment include the client, intended user, intended use, type of opinion, effective date, property characteristics, and assignment conditions. The scope of work should lead to credible results, align with user expectations, and be consistent with peer practices. Valuation standards emphasize the consideration and disclosure of the scope of work in appraisal and review assignments. Appraisers determine what research and analyses are required in their scope of work based on the unique parameters of each assignment.
